On the Effectiveness of Membership Inference in Targeted Data Extraction from Large Language Models

Abstract: LLMs are prone to mem- orizing training data, which poses serious privacy risks. Two of the most prominent concerns are training data extraction and Membership Inference Attacks (MIAs). Prior research has shown that these threats are interconnected: adversaries can extract training data from an LLM by querying the model to generate a large volume of text and subsequently applying MIAs to verify whether a particular data point was included in the training set. In this study, we integrate multiple MIA techniques into the data extraction pipeline to systematically benchmark their effectiveness. We then compare their performance in this integrated setting against results from conventional MIA bench- marks, allowing us to evaluate their practical utility in real-world extraction scenarios.