Evaluation of Vortex Criteria by Virtue of the Quadruple Decomposition of Velocity Gradient Tensor

Abstract: Based on the analysis of the velocity gradient tensor, we investigate in this paper the physical interpretation and limitations of four vortex criteria: $\omega$, $Q$, $\varDelta$ and $\lambda_{ci}$, and reveal the actual physical meaning of vortex patterns which are usually illustrated by level sets of various vortex criteria. A quadruple decomposition based on the normality of the velocity gradient tensor is proposed for the first time, which resolves the motion of a fluid element into dilation, axial stretch along the normal frame, in-plane distortion, and simple shear, in order to clarify the kinematical interpretation of various vortex criteria. The mean rotation characterized by the vorticity $\omega$ always consists of simple shear; the $Q$-criterion can reflect the strength of net rotation within the invariant plane relative to the axial stretch of a fluid element, and it is a sufficient but unnecessary condition for the existence of net rotation; the $\varDelta$-criterion can exactly identify the existence of net rotation, but it is not the strength of net rotation; in the case that net rotation exists, $\lambda_{ci}$ characterize its absolute strength. net rotation is the total effect of the normal rotation within the invariant plane and the simple shear, where the former is the most basic rotation. The newly introduced quadruple decomposition can improve our understanding of vortices in fluids and their motions.