Confidence Intervals for Selected Parameters

Abstract: Practical or scientific considerations often lead to selecting a subset of parameters as important.'' Inferences about those parameters often are based on the same data used to select them in the first place. That can make the reported uncertainties deceptively optimistic: confidence intervals that ignore selection generally have less than their nominal coverage probability. Controlling the probability that one or more intervals for selected parameters do not cover---thesimultaneous over the selected'' (SoS) error rate---is crucial in many scientific problems. Intervals that control the SoS error rate can be constructed in ways that take advantage of knowledge of the selection rule. We construct SoS-controlling confidence intervals for parameters deemed the most ``important'' $k$ of $m$ shift parameters because they are estimated (by independent estimators) to be the largest. The new intervals improve substantially over \v{S}id\'{a}k intervals when $k$ is small compared to $m$, and approach the standard Bonferroni-corrected intervals when $k \approx m$. Standard, unadjusted confidence intervals for location parameters have the correct coverage probability for $k=1$, $m=2$ if, when the true parameters are zero, the estimators are exchangeable and symmetric.