Causality without potential outcomes and the dynamic approach (1905.01195v1)

Abstract: Several approaches to causal inference from observational studies have been proposed. Since the proposal of Rubin (1974) many works have developed a counterfactual approach to causality, statistically formalized by potential outcomes. Pearl (2000) has put forward a theory of structural causal models which gives an important role to graphical models and do not necessarily use potential outcomes. On the other hand, several authors have developed a dynamical approach in line with Granger (1969). We analyze prospective and retrospective causal questions and their different modalities. Following Dawid (2000) we develop criticisms about the potential outcome approach and we show that causal effects can be estimated without potential outcomes: in particular direct computation of the marginal effect can be done by a change of probability measure. Finally, we highlight the need to adopt a dynamic approach to causality through two examples, "truncation by death" and the "obesity paradox".