Dice Question Streamline Icon: https://streamlinehq.com

Dominant driver of disk evolution: turbulence versus winds

Ascertain whether the secular evolution of protoplanetary disks is dominated primarily by turbulent angular momentum transport or by magnetized wind torques, and characterize the strength and nature of turbulence in primarily wind-driven disks.

Information Square Streamline Icon: https://streamlinehq.com

Background

The paper surveys possible evolution drivers: infall, internal angular momentum redistribution (e.g., MRI or VSI turbulence), and mass/angular momentum loss in winds (photoevaporation or magnetized winds). Recent observations often favor weak turbulence and wind-driven accretion, but the prevailing mechanism and the turbulence properties in such disks remain critical for all subsequent formation stages.

References

Open questions and problems that I would like to see resolved include, in no particular order: Do disks evolve mostly due to turbulent or wind torques? Magnetized winds are currently favored, but even if the basic question is considered resolved, the strength and nature of the turbulence in primarily wind-driven disks is still of fundamental importance for planet formation.

Planet formation theory: an overview (2412.11064 - Armitage, 15 Dec 2024) in Section “Some open questions”, Item 4