Dice Question Streamline Icon: https://streamlinehq.com

Smooth versus radially concentrated planet formation

Determine whether planet formation proceeds smoothly across disk radii or is radially concentrated at deterministic disk locations such as ice lines, particle traps, or migration null points.

Information Square Streamline Icon: https://streamlinehq.com

Background

Observations reveal common substructures (rings, crescents, spirals) in disks, and theory predicts special radial locations (e.g., ice lines) that can trap solids or alter migration. Establishing whether planet formation is broadly distributed or concentrated in such zones would reshape models of initial conditions and growth pathways.

References

Open questions and problems that I would like to see resolved include, in no particular order: Is planet formation smoothly distributed or radially concentrated at special disk locations? Protoplanetary disks contain ice lines, and probably other deterministic radial locations where the disk physics creates particle traps or planet migration null points. The basic paradigm for planet formation could yet be either smooth or ring-like.

Planet formation theory: an overview (2412.11064 - Armitage, 15 Dec 2024) in Section “Some open questions”, Item 3