Topological initialness of terminally connected geometric morphisms

Develop and formalize a precise notion of "topological internalization" under which terminally connected geometric morphisms can be characterized as "topologically initial," and establish a rigorous relation between terminally connected geometric morphisms and initial functors, potentially via properties of bicomma topoi or related topological structures.

Background

The authors show that pro-etale morphisms correspond to discrete opfibrations (including at the level of points), while terminally connected morphisms do not generally induce initial functors between categories of points. They nonetheless prove that for any terminally connected geometric morphism, the bicomma topos over a point is connected, suggesting a form of initialness.

On this basis, the authors conjecture a subtler relation between terminally connected morphisms and initial functors, proposing that terminally connected morphisms are "topologically initial" in a sense to be made precise through a future notion of "topological internalization."

References

As disappointing as the previous remark may sound, we nevertheless conjecture a subtler relation between those two classes. ... We hope such a statement will be made more precise in a future work relying on a convenient notion of "topological internalization".

On a (terminally connected, pro-etale) factorization of geometric morphisms  (2502.04213 - Caramello et al., 6 Feb 2025) in Section 6.3, final remark