Dice Question Streamline Icon: https://streamlinehq.com

Stricter discrete opfibrations in multicategories

Determine whether there exist pairs of diagrams in a multicategory that are weakly equivalent when weak equivalence is defined using the stricter notion of discrete opfibration that allows lifts against multimorphisms with a lifted domain, and, if so, provide explicit examples or characterize such cases.

Information Square Streamline Icon: https://streamlinehq.com

Background

In the general 2-categorical setting, the paper adopts a broad notion of discrete opfibration (Definition 2-categorical-dopf) that suffices to prove the main localization results for multicategories.

The authors note that, specifically for multicategories, there exists a natural stricter notion of discrete opfibration that permits lifts against multimorphisms with a lifted domain. While the main results are established for the broader notion, the status of weak equivalences defined using the stricter notion is left unresolved.

The open question concerns whether there are concrete, nontrivial examples of diagrams in multicategories that become weakly equivalent only when the stricter lifting requirement is used, potentially revealing a difference between the broader and stricter notions of discrete opfibration in practice.

References

There exists a natural stricter notion of discrete opfibration, allowing for lifts against multimorphisms with a lifted domain. We thus will be able to describe the localization of the category of diagrams in a multicategory at weak equivalences defined with respect to this broader notion of discrete opfibration; we leave open the question of whether there are interesting examples of diagrams in a multicategory only weakly equivalent with respect to the stricter discrete opfibrations.

The diagrammatic presentation of equations in categories (2401.09751 - Arlin et al., 18 Jan 2024) in Remark “about-2-categorical-dopfs”, item (ii.), Section 5 (The general 2-categorical story)