Sophistication-selection conjecture

Determine whether subjects who are most capable of evaluating a personalized-memory rights bundle also possess the most valuable personalized memories.

Background

The paper identifies a possible selection mechanism in which subjects with greater ability to understand or evaluate rights terms may also have more valuable memory. If true, this correlation would amplify the composition effects in the authorization market, because the subjects best able to protect themselves could be disproportionately valuable targets. The relationship is presented as a conjecture and remains empirically unresolved.

References

Sophistication selection, the conjecture that the subjects most able to evaluate a rights bundle are also those with the most valuable memory, would if true make Proposition~\ref{prop:selection}'s composition effect worse than we report and is straightforwardly testable on any live marketplace.

— Beyond Provenance: The Economics and Governance of Personalized AI Memory  (2609.25521 - Chen et al., 22 Sep 2026) in Section 10, Discussion and Limitations