Resolve collision-label scope and flooding-rate dependence

Determine whether the collision-label discrepancy caused by counting network-wide resource overlaps while the analytical collision probability considers only in-range collisions, and characterize how the reference implementation’s collision probability varies with attacker rate and population by sweeping those parameters.

Background

The paper distills NR PC5 sidelink Mode-2 reception behavior from ns-3 5G-LENA into NS3Learn for use in the Veins/OMNeT++/SUMO stack. One component of the model concerns collisions caused by overlapping resource reservations. However, the collision labels extracted from ns-3 5G-LENA count overlaps anywhere in the network, whereas the analytical collision expression in Equation (\eqref{eq:pcol}) considers collisions among in-range vehicles. Consequently, the two quantities are not measured over identical populations.

The paper also evaluates the surrogate under a single high-rate flooding condition, despite observing that the reference implementation’s collision probability changes with attacker rate. The authors explicitly leave unresolved both the comparability of the collision measurements and the general dependence of collision probability on attacker rate and attacker population, proposing parameter sweeps as the means to resolve them.

References

Two questions stay open. Our collision label counts an overlap anywhere in the network while Equation~eq:pcol resolves collisions in range alone, so the two are not measured over the same set. And the reference implementation's collision probability rises with attacker rate, by $0.339$ at 200 packets per second and $0.393$ at 1000 at the sparsest density, while we evaluate the surrogate at the higher rate alone. Sweeping attacker rate and population would settle both.

— NS3Learn: Transferring 5G NR Mode-2 Reception Realism from ns-3 to the Veins/SUMO Stack for Connected-Vehicle Safety Assessment  (2609.20578 - Bello et al., 17 Sep 2026) in Section Conclusions, final paragraph on scope and open questions