Ontological equivalence of matrix mechanics and wave mechanics

Ascertain whether Heisenberg’s matrix mechanics and Schrödinger’s wave mechanics describe the same physical reality or merely compute empirically equivalent outcomes, despite their formal equivalence within Hilbert-space theory.

Background

After demonstrating the procedural unification of matrix and wave mechanics and recalling von Neumann’s formal equivalence, the essay emphasizes a remaining philosophical question about their ontological status. It asks whether the two formalisms are not only mathematically equivalent but also describe the same reality.

This unresolved issue underscores the paper’s central theme: formal unification does not necessarily resolve epistemic or metaphysical differences between representational and operational modes of understanding in quantum theory.

References

What remains unsettled is whether they describe the same reality or merely compute the same outcomes.

From Heisenberg and Schrödinger to the P vs. NP Problem (2511.07502 - Weinstein, 10 Nov 2025) in Section 3. Algorithmic Quantum Mechanics (end of Subsection 3.1. The Harmonic Oscillator Example)