Determine the nesting of adjoint coarse-graining ranges for generic coarse-grained models

Determine whether the ranges of the adjoint coarse-graining maps satisfy the nesting property \({\rm Ran}[\mathcal I_k^*] \subset {\rm Ran}[\mathcal I_{k+1}^*]\) for every consecutive pair of scales in a generic coarse-grained model, equivalently whether \({\rm Ker}[\mathcal I_{k+1}] \subset {\rm Ker}[\mathcal I_k]\).

Background

The proposed refinement maps require isometric embeddings between coarse Hilbert spaces that also satisfy transitivity. A direct construction using ImIk\mathcal I_m\mathcal I_k^* fails because the adjoint coarse-graining maps are not generally partial isometries and because the required nesting of their ranges has not been established.

The authors introduce iterated coarse-graining maps Ck\mathcal C_k to enforce a related kernel-nesting property and then use polar decompositions to construct refinement maps. Thus, the unresolved question concerns the original coarse-graining maps Ik\mathcal I_k for a generic model, rather than the validity of the alternative construction actually adopted.

References

However, the nesting property is either true by construction within a given model or it is not, and it is equivalent to the statement that ${\rm Ker}[\mathcal I_{k+1}] \subset {\rm Ker}[\mathcal I_k]$ for any $k\in \mathbbm N+$. At present, we can neither prove nor disprove this statement for a generic coarse-grained model.

Coarse-grained models for loop quantum gravity and their renormalization  (2608.31152 - Assanioussi et al., 31 Aug 2026) in Section 5.1, Construction of the refinement maps for the coarse-grained models