Exact entropy production requires unknown time-reversed transition matrix

Determine the exact total entropy production S_tot for the context-to-answer topic transition in the LLM bipartite information engine by identifying the time-reversed transition matrix A^R that appears in the entropy production formula and satisfies the required row-stochastic and marginal constraints (p^{(a)} and p^{(c)}), so that S_tot can be computed exactly rather than via lower bounds.

Background

The paper models LLM answer generation as a stochastic transformation of topic distributions from context (p{(c)}) to answer (p{(a)}) using a forward transition matrix A, and defines total entropy production using the Kullback–Leibler divergence between forward and time-reversed paths. Computing this quantity requires the reverse transition matrix AR of the time-reversed process.

Because AR is not observed from data, the authors cannot compute the exact entropy production and instead propose minimizing over admissible AR to obtain a lower bound. This leaves unresolved the determination of the exact entropy production for the given QCA triplet and transition dynamics, motivating methods to recover AR or otherwise compute S_tot exactly.

References

As the reverse transition matrix $ {f A}R $ is not directly measured, the exact amount of entropy production according to Eq.(\ref{Sdot_tot}) is unknown.

Semantic Faithfulness and Entropy Production Measures to Tame Your LLM Demons and Manage Hallucinations (2512.05156 - Halperin, 4 Dec 2025) in Section 4.4 (Lower Bound on Semantic Entropy Production)