White-noise tolerance of alternative witnesses for the Shifts state

Determine whether an entanglement witness different from the canonical Shifts projector witness can achieve a larger white-noise tolerance for detecting entanglement in the Shifts bound-entangled state.

Background

The paper proves that the canonical projector witness for the three-qubit Shifts unextendible product basis is optimal in the Lewenstein spanning sense: no nonzero positive semidefinite operator can be subtracted while preserving block positivity. It also derives the witness’s exact white-noise detection threshold, namely p_W = 2 - 3√6/4 ≈ 0.162883.

The authors explicitly distinguish this spanning-property optimality from maximal white-noise tolerance among all possible entanglement witnesses detecting the same Shifts state. They note that state-tailored witnesses can outperform UPB projector witnesses in related settings, leaving unresolved whether another witness can provide a higher white-noise tolerance for the Shifts state.

References

The present construction therefore provides an analytically exact witness that is optimal in the Lewenstein spanning sense, together with its closed-form white-noise threshold; whether a different witness yields a larger white-noise tolerance remains an open numerical question.

— Complete product-state contact set and optimality of the canonical three-qubit Shifts witness  (2609.39332 - Wan et al., 30 Sep 2026) in Section 6, Discussion and outlook