Multiloop Vacuum Amplitudes in QFT and Strings

• Multiloop vacuum amplitudes are defined as Feynman integrals with zero external legs, serving as essential building blocks in high-order QFT and string computations.
• They leverage causal decomposition and loop-tree duality to isolate physical singularities, enabling robust handling of UV divergences and reliable numerical integration.
• Graph-theoretic approaches combined with quantum algorithms yield regulator-independent, efficient evaluations crucial for advancements in collider phenomenology and theoretical models.

Multiloop vacuum amplitudes constitute the fundamental building blocks for high-order computations in quantum field theory and string theory. Defined as path-integral or Feynman-diagrammatic contributions with zero external legs, they arise in contexts as diverse as the calculation of UV divergences in gauge and gravity theories, the functional kernels for collider predictions, and the modular-integral representations of the string-theoretic vacuum. Recent developments in causal representations, graph-theoretic decompositions, and quantum-computing strategies are reshaping both the conceptual and computational landscape of these amplitudes (Rodrigo, 2 Jan 2026, Ramírez-Uribe et al., 2024, Bern et al., 2012, Ishibashi et al., 2013, Danilov, 2015).

1. Mathematical Definition and Feynman Representation

In D-dimensional scalar quantum field theory, the L-loop vacuum amplitude with N internal propagators is defined by the standard Feynman integral:

$$V^{(L)} = \int \left[ \prod_{i=1}^L \frac{d^Dk_i}{(2\pi)^D} \right] \prod_{j=1}^N \frac{1}{q_j^2 - m_j^2 + i0}$$

Each $q_j$ is a linear combination of the loop momenta $\{k_i\}$. For instance, in the two-loop "sunrise" diagram ($L=2,N=3$), $q_1=k_1$, $q_2=k_2$, $q_3=k_1+k_2$.

Vacuum diagrams are essential for renormalization (defining counterterms) and for deriving effective actions. In gauge theories and gravity, expansions around vanishing background fields further emphasize the role of vacuum amplitudes in determining ultraviolet properties (Bern et al., 2012).

2. Loop–Tree Duality and Causal Decomposition

Loop–Tree Duality (LTD) provides a representation of multiloop vacuum amplitudes as sums over "single-cut" integrals, transforming each multi-loop integral into a sum over on-shell configurations with manifest causality. The master formula reads:

$$V^{(L)} = -2\,\text{Re}\,\sum_{C \in \text{Cuts}} \int \left[ \prod_{i=1}^L \frac{d^Dk_i}{(2\pi)^D} \right] \Bigg( \prod_{j \in \text{Uncut}} G_F(q_j) \Bigg) \Bigg( \prod_{\ell \in \text{Cut}} \widetilde{\delta}(q_\ell) \Bigg)$$

where $G_F(q) = 1/(q^2 - m^2 + i0)$, $$\widetilde{\delta}(q) = 2\pi i\, \theta(q_0)\, \delta(q^2 - m^2)$$. The sum is over all choices of a single propagator to cut per loop; the $i0$ prescription and the $\theta(q_0)$ factor ensure only forward-in-time (causal) configurations contribute (Rodrigo, 2 Jan 2026, Collaboration et al., 2024, Ramírez-Uribe et al., 2024).

This decomposition isolates physical singularities and eliminates non-causal or threshold artifacts at the integrand level, leading to numerically robust and physically transparent representations. LTD forms the basis for the "LTD causal unitary" framework that reconstructs all real and virtual corrections in collider physics from a kernel vacuum diagram (Ramírez-Uribe et al., 2024).

3. Graph-Theoretic and Causal Structure

The causal structure of multiloop vacuum amplitudes is intricately connected to the properties of the underlying diagram graph $G = (V, E)$. Key elements include:

• Spanning Trees and Cut Sets: A spanning tree $T \subset E$ is a maximal acyclic subset of edges. Its complement $C = E \setminus T$ (the cut set, $|C|=L$) labels the single-cut contributions in the LTD expansion.
• Orientation and Acyclicity: Assigning a direction ("orientation" $\omega$) to each edge, a configuration is causal iff the resulting directed graph is acyclic (i.e., a Directed Acyclic Graph, DAG).
• Correspondence Theorems: Each causal contribution is in one-to-one correspondence with a spanning tree of $G$. Contributions from cuts for which the corresponding graph orientation is acyclic are free of non-causal or threshold singularities; all remaining singularities have a standard physical interpretation (Rodrigo, 2 Jan 2026).

This graph-theoretic classification directly motivates algorithmic strategies for causal detection and enumerates all relevant contributions to a given vacuum amplitude.

4. Applications in Gauge Theory, Gravity, and Collider Phenomenology

4.1 Ultraviolet Properties and Duality

In $\mathcal{N}=4$ super Yang-Mills and $\mathcal{N}=8$ supergravity, the UV divergence structure at four loops can be completely captured by a small set of vacuum integrals. For instance, both the subleading-color divergence in gauge theory and the leading divergence in supergravity are governed by the combination $V_1+2V_2+V_8$ of 11-propagator vacuum graphs (Bern et al., 2012). This alignment provides strong evidence for deep gauge–gravity dualities realized at loop level.

4.2 LTD Causal Unitary Framework for Collider Observables

The "LTD causal unitary" approach posits that all real and virtual contributions at fixed order for collider observables can be assembled as residues (cuts) of a single multiloop vacuum kernel. The kernel is manifestly gauge invariant, automatically incorporates wave-function renormalization, and achieves local UV, IR, and threshold singularity cancellation before integration.

For any process at order $N^k$LO, the differential cross section or decay rate is written as a sum over phase-space residues of the vacuum kernel, with local subtraction of UV (and, conjecturally, initial-state collinear) singularities at the integrand level in $d=4$ (Ramírez-Uribe et al., 2024, Collaboration et al., 2024).

5. Multiloop Vacuum Amplitudes in String Theory

5.1 Bosonic String (Noncritical and Critical Dimensions)

In the light-cone gauge closed bosonic string field theory, the $h$-loop vacuum amplitude is constructed as an integral over the moduli space of genus-$h$ Riemann surfaces. For $d\neq26$, the amplitude is made BRST-invariant by including a nonstandard worldsheet theory for longitudinal fields $X^\pm$ and the $bc$ ghost system. The resulting amplitude integrates over the Weil–Petersson measure, with explicit insertions and anomaly-cancelling terms to regulate divergences via analytic continuation in $d$ (Ishibashi et al., 2013).

5.2 Superstring Theory and Vanishing Vacuum Amplitudes

For the Ramond–Neveu–Schwarz formalism of the closed oriented superstring, the arbitrary-loop vacuum amplitude is constructed as an integral over super-Schottky moduli parametrizing the (1|1) supermanifold. The local integrand features sums over (super-)spin structures, full matter and ghost partition functions, and step-function prescriptions ensuring integration over fundamental domains in both bosonic and Grassmann variables. All divergent configurations are locally compensated:

• Degenerate handles and superpoint collisions yield only integrable singularities;
• All would-be divergences cancel due to the interplay of matter and ghost determinants, with boundary contributions from the step-function expansion. A fundamental result is that the $n$-loop vacuum amplitude vanishes identically ($A_0^{(n)}=0$ for all $n$), in accord with space–time supersymmetry and the GSO projection (Danilov, 2015).

6. Quantum Computing and Algorithmic Strategies

Quantum algorithms offer novel approaches to the identification and integration of causal configurations in multiloop vacuum amplitudes (Rodrigo, 2 Jan 2026):

• Qubit Encoding: Each propagator's orientation is encoded as one qubit; the register represents a superposition of all possible momentum-flow orientations.
• Oracle for Acyclicity: Grover-style search, with multicontrolled Toffoli gates marking cycle conditions, efficiently projects to the causal (acyclic) subspace. Minimum Clique Partition (MCP) of the Mutually Exclusive Clause (MEC) graph further optimizes ancilla requirements, scaling linearly in the number of independent cycles.
• Quantum Amplitude Estimation and Importance Sampling: QFIAE achieves a quadratic speedup in integral estimation by estimating Fourier modes, while QAIS leverages parametrized quantum circuits for adaptive importance sampling with possible exponential advantages for highly correlated integrands.
• Scaling: The oracle construction and quantum integration approaches thus anticipate polynomial or exponential reductions in computational complexity compared to classical Monte Carlo, especially significant for high-loop, high-dimensional configurations (Rodrigo, 2 Jan 2026).

7. Local Cancellation Mechanisms and Regulator Independence

The LTD-based approach guarantees that sums over phase-space cuts of the multiloop vacuum amplitude exhibit complete local cancellation of UV, IR, and threshold singularities in four physical dimensions (Ramírez-Uribe et al., 2024, Collaboration et al., 2024). For example:

• Soft and collinear singularities correspond to limits in causal propagators ($\lambda\to0$); only a finite set of residues diverges in each region. Their sum is locally integrable.
• Threshold singularities are precisely matched and canceled among different residues.
• UV divergences are isolated and subtracted pointwise using a large-momentum expansion of the on-shell energies.

As a result, the post-subtraction integrand is everywhere locally finite, and no explicit dimensional regularization is required. In string theory, analogous cancellation and regularity are achieved via the structure of the worldsheet CFT, modular invariance, and the structure of the ghost and matter partition functions (Ishibashi et al., 2013, Danilov, 2015).

---

A synthesis of causal duality, graph-theoretic structure, and advanced quantum algorithms has established the multiloop vacuum amplitude as a central computational object for both theoretical and phenomenological high-energy physics, with applications spanning gauge theory divergence structure, collider event generation, and the foundational vanishing theorems of string theory.