Multilevel Readout Protocol

• Multilevel readout protocols are quantum measurement schemes that utilize multiple system states and channels to overcome the limitations of binary readouts.
• They incorporate techniques such as frequency division multiplexing, shelving, and ancilla-assisted methods to enable parallel, high-fidelity readouts in advanced quantum architectures.
• Advanced implementations integrate machine learning and error mitigation strategies to optimize speed, reduce crosstalk, and support scalable quantum processors.

A multilevel readout protocol refers to any quantum measurement scheme that extracts state information from quantum systems (such as qubits, qudits, or multilevel memories) by leveraging multiple system levels, multiplexed channels, or advanced hardware/software co-designs to achieve scalability, fidelity, or efficiency beyond standard two-level readout approaches. Multilevel protocols are central to scalable measurement in superconducting, spin, and hybrid quantum architectures, as well as in advanced detector systems, and appear in the form of frequency division multiplexing, repeated or error-corrected readout, shelving and ancilla-based protocols, and scalable readout with machine learning postprocessing.

1. Fundamental Principles of Multilevel Readout

Multilevel readout protocols exploit the presence of multiple accessible measurement channels, physical states, or system levels to address the limitations of conventional two-level (binary) readout. Rather than restricting measurement to population discrimination between |0⟩ and |1⟩, these protocols either: (i) resolve occupation across multiple excited or computational/extracomputational states; (ii) use multiple readout resonators/frequencies or technology-specific multiplexing; or (iii) combine these concepts to enable parallel, high-fidelity, and state-selective measurement.

In circuit QED architectures, the central mechanism is the dispersive interaction between the quantum device and its resonator or measurement channel, where the state-dependent frequency shift enables inference of the system’s state via transmission or reflection measurements. Mathematically, for dispersive readout of a multilevel system,

$$\Delta\omega_r = \frac{\tilde{g}^2}{\omega_q - \omega_r}\,\sigma_z$$

where $\tilde{g}$ is the effective (possibly level-dependent) coupling, and $\omega_q$, $\omega_r$ are the qubit and resonator frequencies, respectively (Jerger et al., 2012, Schmitt et al., 2014, Kundu et al., 2019).

2. Frequency Division Multiplexing and Dispersive Multiplexed Readout

A canonical multilevel protocol is frequency-division multiplexing (FDM) readout, where each qubit or sensor is coupled to a resonator at a unique frequency, all connected to a shared feedline or measurement chain. By generating a comb of probe tones (one for each resonator), amplitude and phase changes induced by each device can be measured simultaneously and separated by digital demodulation (e.g., via FFT). This approach is foundational for state-of-the-art superconducting qubit, spin qubit, and hybrid sensor arrays.

Table: Core Elements of Frequency-Division Multiplexed Readout

Element	Implementation Mechanism	Notable Systems
Resonator array	Multiple resonators with unique frequencies	Coplanar waveguide, lumped-element, LC circuits (Jerger et al., 2012, Chen et al., 2012, Hornibrook et al., 2013)
Probe synthesis	Multi-tone pulse generation (baseband/IF/GHz)	DAC + IQ-mixer, SDR, AWG
Readout line	Single microwave transmission line	Shared feedline
Signal processing	FFT, digital demodulation, per-channel IQ analysis	FPGA, room-temperature SDR (Chen et al., 2012, Richter et al., 2022)

Contextually, FDM solves the scalability bottleneck—readout complexity no longer increases linearly with device number. Experiments demonstrate parallel readout of up to 6–10 devices (flux, phase, spin qubits, MMC detector pixels), with multiplexing factors limited by available bandwidth, crosstalk (dictated by resonator linewidth κ, qubit relaxation γ), and digital/analog electronics capability (Jerger et al., 2012, Hornibrook et al., 2013, Richter et al., 2022).

3. Advanced Protocols: Multilevel Encoding, Shelving, and Ancilla Memory

Protocols utilizing the multilevel Hilbert space, as in transmons or bosonic modes, encode logical information in more than two levels and/or use population shelving to higher states to improve readout fidelity. Typical strategies include:

• Shelving Protocols: Population transfer to higher excited states (e.g., |1⟩ → |2⟩) via π₁₂ pulse before measurement increases the dispersive shift $\chi$ and effective T₁, making measurement more robust to relaxation and improving speed/fidelity. Experiments achieve single-shot readout fidelities of 99–99.9% in 50–300 ns using such protocols (Yen et al., 3 Mar 2024, Xiong et al., 15 Sep 2025).
• Logical Qubits in Higher-Dimensional Codes: By mapping logical information to states such as |g⟩ vs |f⟩, or Fock states |0⟩ vs |L⟩, the protocol gains protection: relaxation through intermediate levels increases the minimum number of decay events required to introduce measurement error, with infidelity scaling as $(t_m/T_1)^n$ for encoding parameter $n$ (Elder et al., 2019).
• Repetitive and Error-Corrected Readout with Ancillae: Storing quantum information in a robust multilevel ancilla (e.g., 14N nuclear spin in NV centers) enables repeated, high-fidelity measurement, with further error correction via SWAP or coherent-feedback operations to counteract measurement backaction. Enhancements by factors up to 13× in fidelity are reported, and further doubled by error correction (~2× improvement) (Holzgrafe et al., 2018).

4. Multiplexed and Machine-Learning-Enhanced Architectures

Recent protocols integrate algorithmic or hardware-centric enhancements for highly parallel, scalable, and efficient readout:

• Broadband Tunable Purcell Filters: Dynamically engineering the bandwidth (κ) of the readout resonator during active measurement and idle periods using a tunable filter—often implemented with an on-chip SQUID—enables optimal SNR for measurement while strongly suppressing photon-noise-induced dephasing and the Purcell effect during idle periods. These filters also facilitate multiplexed readout of many qubits with minimal crosstalk and single-shot fidelity up to 99.9% in 50 ns (Xiao et al., 9 Jul 2025, Xiong et al., 15 Sep 2025).
• Matched Filtering and Neural Nets on FPGAs: For rapid, resource-efficient three-level discrimination and leakage detection (e.g., distinguishing |0⟩, |1⟩, |2⟩ in transmons), a pipeline consisting of per-state matched filters, followed by lightweight neural network classification, reduces FPGA resource usage by ~60× and network size by 100×, allowing real-time operation on commercial FPGAs. This approach reduces QEC cycle time (~20% improvement), mitigates leakage, and achieves fidelity improvement of 6.6% over baseline (Mude et al., 14 May 2024).
• Simultaneous Readout in Detector Arrays: For cryogenic microcalorimeter arrays, frequency-division μMUX (microwave SQUID multiplexing) and flux-ramp modulation allow phase-based multilevel readout and efficient scaling to thousands of pixels per feedline (Richter et al., 2022).

5. Protocols for Error Mitigation and Conditional Readout

Measurement outcomes in protocols that influence subsequent computation (as in mid-circuit or adaptive feedforward circuits) must be treated to mitigate readout error. Standard mitigation is insufficient; thus, PROBabilistic Readout Error Mitigation (PROM) randomizes feedforward (via bitmasking), averages results with specified weights derived from the confusion matrix (Walsh–Hadamard basis), and corrects in post-processing. PROM achieves unbiased estimators with only classical overhead, yielding up to 60% reduction in error infidelity in dynamic circuits (GHZ state preparation, multi-stage teleportation, reset) (Koh et al., 11 Jun 2024).

For analysis of multi-qubit algorithms, particularly those involving entanglement, precise conditional readout probability matrices are constructed by directly counting simultaneous outcomes and thresholding joint IQ data, as opposed to assuming outcome independence (multiplication of single-qubit matrices). This conditional approach improves the Hellinger fidelity of benchmark quantum circuits by several percentage points, essential for accurate algorithm validation (Stasino et al., 31 Mar 2025).

6. Applications and Scalability in Quantum and Classical Systems

Multilevel readout protocols are foundational to:

• Large-scale Quantum Processors: FDM and multiplexed protocols are central to reading out arrays of superconducting or spin qubits, facilitating scaling from a handful to hundreds or more devices (Jerger et al., 2012, Chen et al., 2012, Hornibrook et al., 2013, Kundu et al., 2019, Xiao et al., 9 Jul 2025, Xiong et al., 15 Sep 2025).
• Bosonic, Multimode, or Ancilla-Enhanced Quantum Codes: High-fidelity logical qubit assignment and error detection in error-correcting codes benefit significantly from multilevel approaches that suppress error propagation (Elder et al., 2019).
• Cryogenic Memory and Neuromorphic Applications: Multilevel SQUID memory devices (with up to eight distinct vorticity states) and deterministic phase-slip controls exemplify how multilevel protocols enable efficient, dense data storage and manipulation at cryogenic temperatures, extending beyond strictly quantum computation (Chaves et al., 2022).
• Sensor and Detector Arrays: Frequency multiplexed μMUX readout in magnetic microcalorimeter arrays leverages multilevel readout to scale to massive detector numbers with minimal hardware (Richter et al., 2022).

7. Limitations, Tradeoffs, and Future Directions

Multilevel readout schemes encounter constraints arising from resonator linewidth, channel bandwidth, crosstalk, and hardware imperfections. Increasing the number of multiplexed channels is ultimately limited by the minimal channel spacing (set by κ and qubit relaxation γ) and the total available bandwidth (Jerger et al., 2012). Protocols must also manage tradeoffs between relaxation error and measurement duration, photon noise, and real-time processing capability.

Advances in real-time machine learning, cryogenic-compatible hardware, error mitigation for adaptive circuits, and expanded use of n-level (qudit) systems are emerging as primary themes for continued development. Prospects include further integration of multilevel protocols into full QEC stacks, expansion to higher-dimensional encodings, and co-design of quantum-classical hardware for latency minimization (Mude et al., 14 May 2024, Xiong et al., 15 Sep 2025).

---

Multilevel readout protocols thus constitute a versatile and indispensable suite of techniques for high-fidelity, scalable, and efficient measurement of complex quantum and hybrid systems. Their ongoing evolution directly shapes the architecture and computational reliability of next-generation quantum processors and cryogenic information platforms.