Composition $g$-modes and $f$-modes of neutron stars with gravitationally coupled dark matter: degeneracy with the symmetry energy

Abstract: Composition gravity ($g$) modes have been proposed as a probe of dark matter in neutron stars, on the basis of one-fluid models in which the dark matter is in chemical equilibrium with the neutrons. We computed in full general relativity the $g$- and $f$-modes of stars in which fermionic dark matter couples to the nucleons only through gravity, and inferred the dark mass fraction from NICER and GW170817 data with a prior that comprises $63$ nucleonic equations of state (EOSs) from Skyrme and relativistic mean-field functionals, among them the models of Dutra \textit{et al.} and of the compilation of Sun, Bhattiprolu and Lattimer. The data do not prefer dark matter and bound its mass fraction at $0.12 - 0.26$ ($95\%$) for particle masses of $0.5$--$2$~GeV. Coupled only through gravity, the dark matter reaches the buoyancy that restores a $g$-mode only through the gravitational field: a dark core holding $10\%$ of the mass raises the fundamental $g$-mode by $10-15\%$ at fixed EOS, several times less than in the one-fluid picture. The larger effect is indirect: a star with a dark core needs a stiffer nucleonic EOS, and since the $g$-mode is set by the density dependence of the symmetry energy, its frequency reflects the EOS that the star requires rather than the dark matter it contains; at fixed radius and symmetry energy a core holding $10\%$ of the mass is equivalent to a change of the slope $L$ of $9-12$~MeV. The $f$-mode, which follows the mean density, behaves differently: a dark core breaks the relation between the $f$-mode and the tidal deformability by about one percent, far outside the posterior spread of nucleonic stars.