Making Logical Relations More Relatable (Proof Pearl)

Abstract: Mechanical proofs by logical relations often involve tedious reasoning about substitution. In this paper, we show that this is not necessarily the case, by developing, in Agda, a proof that all simply typed lambda calculus expressions evaluate to values. A formalization of the proof is remarkably short (~40 lines of code), making for an excellent introduction to the technique of proofs by logical relations not only on paper but also in a mechanized setting. We then show that this process extends to more sophisticated reasoning by also proving the totality of normalization by evaluation. Although these proofs are not new, we believe presenting them will empower both new and experienced programming language theorists in their use of logical relations.