Dice Question Streamline Icon: https://streamlinehq.com

Relevance of bibliometrics for Global South research evaluation

Determine the extent to which bibliometric approaches and findings are relevant and useful for research evaluation in Global South contexts, and identify any adaptations or alternative approaches required to align with Global South priorities.

Information Square Streamline Icon: https://streamlinehq.com

Background

The book notes that its analyses and recommendations are largely grounded in a Global North perspective. It questions whether bibliometrics, as commonly practiced and validated in Global North systems, map onto the priorities, outputs, and evaluation needs of Global South research systems, which may emphasize local societal benefits, capacity building, and outputs not well covered by citation indexes.

Clarifying this relevance is central for equitable and effective assessment practices and for avoiding perverse incentives that might push Global South scholars toward indicators that do not reflect their goals.

References

Nevertheless, this book is written primarily from a Global North perspective, and it is not clear that anything in it (or bibliometrics as a field) has any relevance at all to the sometimes-different priorities of Global South research evaluation (see Section 2.2.4).