Dice Question Streamline Icon: https://streamlinehq.com

Do altmetrics capture societal impact beyond citations?

Demonstrate whether specific altmetrics (e.g., Twitter/X mentions, news or blog references, Wikipedia citations, Mendeley readers) capture dimensions of societal impact that are not reflected in scholarly citation counts, and characterize the contexts in which such added value occurs.

Information Square Streamline Icon: https://streamlinehq.com

Background

Altmetrics are often motivated by the promise of evidencing societal attention and impact, complementing citations that primarily reflect scholarly influence. However, empirical validation against robust quality or impact benchmarks is scarce.

Establishing whether and where altmetrics add unique information beyond citations is essential for their credible use in research evaluation.

References

Unfortunately, the data in this chapter does not directly address one of the main claims for altmetrics: that they might reflect a dimension of societal impact that is not well captured by citations (Priem et al, 2011). This hypothesis remains unproven.