Recursive formula for odd-primary Steenrod kernels

Prove or disprove the proposed recursive identity N_k=P^{p^{k-1}}N_{k-1}-\frac{1}{2}N_{k-1}P^{p^{k-1}} for the generator N_k of the first nontrivial kernel of right multiplication by P^{p^{k-1}}\cdots P^1\beta.

Background

The appendix constructs generators N_k for the first nontrivial kernels of right multiplication in the Steenrod algebra using stripping techniques. The authors obtain a complicated recursive formula and report that low-degree computations suggest a simpler relation, which they leave as an explicit question.

References

Does $N_k = P{p{k-1}} N_{k-1} - \frac{1}{2} N_{k-1} P{p{k-1}}$?

— An abelian model for the Goodwillie tower of the circle  (2609.31269 - Nervo, 25 Sep 2026) in Appendix A, final question of Section “Stripping techniques”