Dice Question Streamline Icon: https://streamlinehq.com

Possible distributed H2O source from sublimating icy grains in the outer coma

Ascertain whether there is a significant contribution to the H2O gas in the outer coma of 3I/ATLAS from sublimating icy grains acting as a distributed source, as suggested by the non-asymptotic H2O production-rate curve within the JWST NIRSpec IFU field.

Information Square Streamline Icon: https://streamlinehq.com

Background

Production-rate (Q) curves derived from spectral modeling show CO2 and CO leveling off with distance from the nucleus, indicating near-nuclear sources. In contrast, the H2O Q curve does not clearly asymptote within the IFU field, leaving open the possibility of extended production.

The authors explicitly state that they cannot rule out H2O production from sublimating icy grains in the outer coma, consistent with their detection of coma H2O ice. Resolving whether such a distributed source exists would clarify water production mechanisms and help reconcile differences with ultraviolet OH imaging measurements.

References

Therefore, we cannot rule out a contribution to H$_2$O gas in the outer coma from sublimating icy grains, which may be expected based on our detection of coma H$_2$O ice.

JWST detection of a carbon dioxide dominated gas coma surrounding interstellar object 3I/ATLAS (2508.18209 - Cordiner et al., 25 Aug 2025) in Section 4 (Spectral Modeling), discussion of Q-curves near Figure 4