Determine whether chatbots account for Islamic jurisprudential considerations

Determine whether chatbots take into account relevant Islamic jurisprudential considerations, including madhhab, ijma, and qiyas, when providing religious rulings, knowledge, or guidance.

Background

The paper reports that Muslim participants were concerned about the reliability and religious adequacy of GenAI-generated guidance. In particular, participants feared that chatbots might produce rulings without accounting for the complexity of Islamic jurisprudence or for differences among schools of thought and methods of legal reasoning.

This unresolved question is important because users may rely on chatbot responses for religious rulings while lacking the knowledge needed to identify omissions or misinterpretations. Establishing whether and how chatbots incorporate madhhab, ijma, and qiyas would help assess the risks of using general-purpose GenAI systems for Islamic guidance and inform the design of safer, context-sensitive systems.

References

It is unclear whether chatbots take into account considerations such as madhhab, ijma, or qiyas. Without being sure of this, I believe that relying on chatbots for religious rulings, knowledge, or guidance is highly risky.

— From Mind Mapping to Dream Interpretation: Understanding Muslim Users' Engagement with GenAI Tools in Religious Context  (2610.18549 - Jahan et al., 13 Oct 2026) in Section 4, subsection “Concerns around Interaction for Religious Purposes,” subsubsection “Being Misguided”