Dice Question Streamline Icon: https://streamlinehq.com

Asymptotic behavior of the non-linear dynamics for (pi,k) across rounds

Characterize the asymptotic behavior as i → ∞ of the distribution (pi,k)k∈N describing the proportion of balls that lie in boxes with exactly k balls after round i in the three-throw mystery-balls process with r = ⌊τ t⌋ boxes per throw and independent uniform throws; specifically, analyze the associated non-linear recurrence to determine the existence and form of any limiting distribution and the conditions on τ under which it converges to zero mass versus a positive residual mass.

Information Square Streamline Icon: https://streamlinehq.com

Background

To analyze the success probability of the coefficient-recovery game, the paper defines pi,k as the expected fraction of balls in boxes with k occupants after round i and derives a non-linear update rule relating (pi+1,k) to (pi,k). Winning corresponds to the total remaining fraction tending to zero; losing corresponds to convergence to a positive limit.

While the authors provide numerical evidence and reliable approximations for (pi,k), they explicitly state that a full analytical description of its asymptotic behavior remains out of reach in the paper, leaving open the rigorous characterization of the dynamics and its dependence on τ.

References

We have not yet been able to fully describe the asymptotic behavior of the distribution (pi,k)kEN for i -> co, which follows a non-linear dynamics.

Probably faster multiplication of sparse polynomials (2508.16164 - Hoeven, 22 Aug 2025) in Section 3 (On our probability of winning the game)