Convergence of the AMM hierarchy to the quantum set in the 1-steer-2 scenario

Determine whether the assemblage moment-matrix characterization for the 1-steer-2 tripartite steering scenario converges, as the hierarchy level tends to infinity, to the quantum set, thereby resolving the corresponding convergence question also present in the bipartite steering scenario.

Background

The paper extends the assemblage-moment-matrix (AMM) framework to device-independent quantification of steering in two tripartite configurations: 2-steer-1, where Alice and Bob jointly steer Charlie, and 1-steer-2, where Alice steers the joint Bob–Charlie subsystem. At each finite hierarchy level, the AMM constraints provide semidefinite relaxations of the quantum set.

In the 1-steer-2 configuration, every assemblage satisfying positivity and the consistency condition admits a quantum realization, so post-quantum steering does not arise. Nevertheless, it is not established whether imposing AMM positivity and consistency at all hierarchy levels is sufficient to recover exactly the quantum set. The paper explicitly identifies this convergence issue as unresolved, with an analogous open problem already known in the bipartite AMM framework.

References

Whether the characterization provided by the AMMs converges, as $\ell\to\infty$, to the quantum set therefore remains an open question in this scenario, just as it does in the bipartite one.

— Device-independent quantification of steerability in tripartite scenario  (2609.36907 - Wang et al., 29 Sep 2026) in Section 6.1, “Upper bounds on Tsirelson bounds” (following Eq. (46)); reiterated in Section 7, Conclusion