Dice Question Streamline Icon: https://streamlinehq.com

Explaining the absence of a precipitation curtain in a low-precipitation tornadic supercell

Explain the absence of a precipitation curtain in the Candating, Arayat low-precipitation tornadic supercell despite concurrent radar-indicated hydrometeor presence and elevated lightning activity, by identifying the microphysical and dynamical mechanisms responsible for the storm’s low-precipitation mode.

Information Square Streamline Icon: https://streamlinehq.com

Background

The supercell exhibited low-precipitation characteristics without a precipitation curtain, even though radar analysis indicated ice, graupel, and hail within the updraft and strong electrical activity below the freezing level.

The authors discuss possible hypotheses involving low-level shear, upper-level storm-relative flow, and mid-level moisture structure, but explicitly note that the cause remains unclear, highlighting a need to isolate the controlling microphysical and dynamical processes in this tropical case.

References

However, it is quite unclear to us (authors) why the precipitation curtain is absent in this supercell, thus its LP mode, despite the presence and superposition of cloud hydrometeors.

A Case Study of the Tornadic Supercell in the Province of Pampanga, Philippines (27 May 2024) (2504.20559 - Capuli et al., 29 Apr 2025) in Section 3.4.2 (Lightning and Microphysical Processes), paragraph following Figure 16