Inverse Magnetic Catalysis in QCD

• Inverse magnetic catalysis is the suppression of chiral symmetry breaking by strong magnetic fields, marked by a reduced quark condensate and lowered pseudo-critical temperature.
• Effective models and lattice QCD simulations reveal that the interplay between valence enhancement and sea suppression—with modifications in coupling and Polyakov loop ordering—is key to understanding IMC.
• The phenomenon has practical implications for heavy-ion collision phenomenology and astrophysical systems, as it alters the QCD phase diagram and affects charge fluctuations and meson properties.

Inverse magnetic catalysis (IMC) is the phenomenon wherein, contrary to the familiar magnetic catalysis effect, an external magnetic field suppresses chiral symmetry breaking in QCD-like systems near the chiral crossover. This suppression manifests as a reduction of the quark condensate and/or the relevant (pseudo)critical temperature with increasing magnetic field, especially at finite temperature and density. The IMC effect emerges from the nontrivial interplay between the valence and sea quark sectors, the ordering of the Polyakov loop, and the running of the QCD coupling, as demonstrated by lattice QCD, effective models, and holographic dual constructions.

1. Core Mechanism and Theoretical Basis

IMC is driven by a competition between two opposing mechanisms regarding the influence of an external magnetic field $B$ on the quark condensate %%%%1%%%%:

• Valence effect: The magnetic field, entering explicitly in the Dirac operator, enhances the density of low Dirac eigenmodes. By the Banks–Casher relation,

$$\lim_{\lambda \to 0} \lim_{V \to \infty} \rho(\lambda)\, \pi = \lim_{m \to 0} \lim_{V \to \infty} \langle \bar{\psi} \psi \rangle ,$$

this increases the quark condensate and favors chiral symmetry breaking (“magnetic catalysis”) (Bruckmann et al., 2013).

• Sea effect: Simultaneously, $B$ appears in the quark determinant, altering the probability weight of gauge configurations (“sea” of gluonic backgrounds). For temperatures near $T_c$, the quark determinant suppresses configurations with many small Dirac eigenmodes, acting to “order” the Polyakov loop—an indicator of deconfinement (Bruckmann et al., 2013, Bruckmann et al., 2013). Since an ordered Polyakov loop suppresses the near-zero mode density, chiral symmetry breaking is disadvantaged.

At low temperature, the valence effect dominates, and magnetic catalysis is observed. Near $T_c$, the sea effect overwhelms the valence enhancement, resulting in a net suppression (IMC). Lattice QCD confirms this mechanism: at physical quark masses and for sufficiently strong $B$, the pseudo-critical temperature $T_{pc}$ for chiral restoration decreases as $B$ increases (Bandyopadhyay et al., 2020).

2. Model Implementations and Effective Coupling Modifications

Various effective models incorporate IMC by introducing supplementary mechanisms or promoting parameters—such as the four-quark coupling $G$—to be magnetic field– and temperature–dependent.

• Running coupling scenario: Motivated by lattice QCD and perturbative calculations, $G \to G(eB, T)$ is constructed to decrease with $eB$ at high temperature, mimicking the screening of gluon interactions and thus weakening chiral symmetry breaking in strong magnetic fields (Ayala et al., 2015, Bandyopadhyay et al., 2020, Ferreira et al., 2017, Mao et al., 2022, Li et al., 2023).
• PNJL/Polyakov-sector modifications: The deconfinement transition is encoded via the Polyakov loop potential parameter $T_0$. Letting $T_0 = T_0(eB)$ with decreasing behavior further sharpens the IMC effect and provides quantitative agreement with lattice data on pseudocritical temperature decreases (Mao, 14 Oct 2024).
• Beyond mean-field approaches: Inclusion of mesonic fluctuations, e.g., through Pauli–Villars regularization and “feed-down” from the Goldstone mode, dynamically suppresses the effective coupling $G'$ at high $T$ and strong $B$, providing a consistent explanation of IMC within the NJL framework (Mao, 2016).

Characteristic forms:

$$G(eB) = G_0\, \frac{1 + a\zeta^2 + b\zeta^3}{1 + c\zeta^2 + d\zeta^4},\quad\zeta = \frac{eB}{\Lambda_{QCD}^2}$$

or

$$G(eB) = G_0\, [1 - \gamma\, |eB|/(\Lambda_{QCD}^2\, T/\Lambda_{QCD})]$$

with parameters $a,b,c,d,\gamma$ fixed to reproduce lattice QCD results (Bandyopadhyay et al., 2020, Ferreira et al., 2017).

3. Holographic and Nonlocal Model Insights

Holographic approaches encapsulate IMC through both top-down (e.g., Sakai–Sugimoto, soft-wall AdS/QCD) and bottom-up models:

• Sakai–Sugimoto model: In the NJL-like or nonlocal limit, at finite chemical potential and low temperature, increasing $B$ reduces the critical chemical potential for chiral symmetry restoration—a clear IMC signature. This results from the energetic cost of pairing quarks and antiquarks with mismatched Fermi surfaces, analogous to the Clogston–Chandrasekhar limit in superconductivity. The competition is succinctly captured in the free energy difference (Preis et al., 2010):

$$\Delta\Omega \propto B \left( \frac{M^2}{2} - \mu^2 \right) .$$

IMC persists up to $|qB| \lesssim 10^{19}$ G at $T\simeq0$.

• Soft-wall AdS/QCD: The magnetic field enters via backreacted geometry. The effective dilaton,

$$\phi(z) = \Phi(z) - \log\big( \sqrt{q(z) h(z)} \big),$$

modifies the chiral transition so that increased $B$ suppresses the condensate and shifts $T_c$ downward (Li et al., 2016).

• Nonlocal chiral quark models: The momentum–dependent (and $B$–dependent) mass function introduces a natural IMC in the mean-field approximation without requiring an explicit running coupling, contrasting with local models which require explicit $G(eB)$ input (Pagura et al., 2016).

4. Lattice QCD Results and Experimental Relevance

Lattice QCD simulations definitively demonstrate IMC:

• For physical pion masses, the condensate decreases and $T_{pc}$ is suppressed with $B$ near the transition (Bruckmann et al., 2013, Bruckmann et al., 2013, Bandyopadhyay et al., 2020).
• The decomposition into valence and sea contributions, with only the latter reducing the condensate around $T_c$, is confirmed numerically, and connected to Polyakov loop ordering.
• These observations govern the calibration of effective models intended for phenomenological applications involving heavy-ion collisions and astrophysical contexts.

In the hadron resonance gas and Polyakov-loop extended NJL (PNJL) models, implementing IMC via $G(eB)$ or $T_0(eB)$ alters thermodynamic susceptibilities and conserved charge fluctuations. Enhanced correlations and quadratic fluctuations of baryon number and electric charge are obtained when IMC is incorporated, better matching lattice data (Mao, 14 Oct 2024, Mohapatra, 2017).

5. Extensions and Related Phenomena

• Inverse magneto-rotational catalysis (IMRC): The suppression of chiral symmetry breaking is further amplified when magnetic fields act in concert with global rotation, especially evident in phase diagrams where the critical temperature and angular frequency thresholds both decrease as $B$ rises (Sadooghi et al., 2021).
• Axial inverse magnetic catalysis (AIMC): When anomalous magnetic moments are included, inverse catalysis is observed also for the $U(1)_A$ symmetry sector, with both chiral and axial susceptibilities showing reduced critical temperatures under increasing $B$ (Wang et al., 2021).
• Meson sector effects: IMC leads to substantive shifts in screening/mass differences of chiral partners (e.g., $\pi^0$ and $\sigma$ mesons). The transition temperature determined from the merger of chiral partner masses tracks the condensate-based $T_{pc}$ and shifts downward with $B$ in lattice-improved models (Sheng et al., 2021).

6. Quantitative Features and Parameter Dependencies

• Critical temperature behavior: In the presence of IMC, the pseudo-critical temperature $T_{pc}(eB)$ is a monotonically decreasing function of $eB$, in contrast to the standard magnetic catalysis case.
• Critical chemical potential (holography): At $T\simeq 0$, the critical chemical potential $\mu_{c}(b)$ in the Sakai–Sugimoto model decreases as $B$ increases for moderate $B$, see:

$$\mu_c(b=0) \simeq \frac{0.44}{\ell^2},\quad \mu_c(b\to\infty) \simeq \frac{0.43}{\ell^2}$$

with nonmonotonicity in between (Preis et al., 2010).

• Pion sector: In two-flavor NJL phenomenology, with $G(eB)$ decreasing, Mott transition temperatures for neutral and charged pions are systematically reduced at fixed $B$, and the effect depends nontrivially on current quark mass (Li et al., 2023).
• Charge fluctuations: In effective and HRG models, the IMC effect can increase fluctuations and correlations along the freeze-out curve relative to the standard $B=0$ case and significantly change net-kaon moments, emphasizing the importance of self-consistent freeze-out conditions (Mohapatra, 2017, Mao, 14 Oct 2024).

7. Implications for the QCD Phase Diagram and Heavy-Ion Phenomenology

• Phase structure: IMC modifies the topology of the QCD phase diagram—shrinking the chiral symmetry–broken domain, shifting the critical end point (CEP) to lower chemical potentials with increasing $B$, or potentially changing the order of the chiral transition at $\mu=0$ to first order for sufficiently strong magnetic fields (Ferreira et al., 2017).
• Application domains: The effect is relevant for interpreting data from ultrarelativistic heavy-ion collisions, where enormous magnetic fields can arise, and for astrophysical environments such as magnetars, where modifications to the chiral and deconfinement transition lines due to $B$ may affect observable properties.
• Model building: Any realistic effective model for QCD under external magnetic fields, especially for the transition region, must incorporate both valence and sea effects, the Polyakov loop response, and allow for magnetic field–dependent effective couplings to capture IMC as observed in lattice QCD.

---

Inverse magnetic catalysis encapsulates the nontrivial and counterintuitive reduction of chiral symmetry breaking in QCD and QCD-like theories under strong magnetic fields at high temperature and/or density, with profound implications for the structure of the QCD phase diagram, phenomenology of relativistic heavy-ion collisions, and the modeling of dense astrophysical systems. Its robust observation in lattice QCD and consistent reproduction in diverse theoretical frameworks supports its relevance as a defining feature of QCD matter in extreme environments.