Discrete Time-Crystal Phases

• Discrete time-crystal phases are defined as stable non-equilibrium states in driven many-body systems, marked by spontaneous breaking of discrete time-translation symmetry.
• Experimental implementations in cavity and circuit QED show robust period-doubling and multiplet oscillations through modulated atom–light coupling and engineered dissipation.
• Theoretical analysis combines Floquet and Lindblad frameworks to reveal universal scaling laws and exponentially long lifetimes of time-crystalline order.

Discrete time-crystal (DTC) phases are non-equilibrium dynamical phases of periodically driven (Floquet) many-body systems, characterized by a spontaneous breaking of discrete time-translation symmetry. When formed, local observables exhibit robust oscillations with a period that is an integer multiple of the driving period, in contrast to the drive's fundamental period. DTC phases have been realized and analyzed in open and closed quantum systems, including platforms such as cavity and circuit quantum electrodynamics (QED), where strong coupling and engineered dissipation stabilize the time-crystalline order (Gong et al., 2017). This entry details the precise definition, dynamical mechanism, theoretical structure, experimental implementation, analysis of phase diagrams, and mathematical formalism relevant to discrete time-crystal phases, with particular emphasis on the driven-dissipative open Dicke model and related realizations.

1. Definition and Fundamental Characteristics

A discrete time crystal is defined as a stable out-of-equilibrium phase in which, under periodic driving with period $T$, the stroboscopic evolution of a local observable repeats only after an integer multiple $nT$ (with $n \geq 2$) of the driving period—even though the drive Hamiltonian is itself $T$-periodic: $$H(t + T) = H(t), \quad \langle O(t + nT) \rangle = \langle O(t) \rangle,~n \geq 2$$ This constitutes the spontaneous breaking of discrete time-translation symmetry. Such subharmonic temporal order is stabilized by many-body interactions, long-range correlations, or their interplay with dissipation. The DTC behavior is robust—it does not originate from explicit period multiplication in the drive, nor is it a trivial resonance response.

In the context of the open Dicke model, these features arise from a combination of strong atom–light coupling, nontrivial phase space structure (bifurcations and limit cycles), and engineered Lindbladian dissipation (Gong et al., 2017). Unlike spatial or internal symmetry breaking in equilibrium phases, here the temporal ordering emerges as the key organizational principle.

2. Experimental Realization: Modulated Open Dicke Model

The driven-dissipative Dicke model consists of $N$ two-level atoms (pseudospins) collectively coupled to a single cavity mode, with coherent and dissipative dynamics governed by a Lindblad master equation: $$\frac{d\rho}{dt} = -i[H(\lambda), \rho] + \kappa \mathcal{D}[a] \rho$$ where

$$H(\lambda) = \omega a^\dagger a + \omega_0 J_z + \frac{2\lambda}{\sqrt{N}} (a + a^\dagger) J_x$$

and $$\mathcal{D}[a]\rho = a\rho a^\dagger - \frac{1}{2}\{a^\dagger a, \rho\}$$. The coupling strength $\lambda$ is subject to periodic modulation: $$\lambda(t + T) = \lambda(t) = \begin{cases} \lambda, & 0 \leq t < T/2 \ 0, & T/2 \leq t < T \end{cases}$$ The periodic protocol effectively alternates atom–light coupling in a way that realizes a parity operation between two symmetry-broken steady states.

Realizations in both cavity QED (with tunable atom–cavity coupling) and circuit QED (with dynamically controlled coupling between superconducting qubits and resonator modes) are feasible. In all platforms, photon loss (dissipation, at rate $\kappa$) serves not as a detrimental decoherence source but as a stabilizing mechanism for the DTC, ensuring long-lived temporal order even in the presence of fluctuations.

3. Dynamical Phases and Bifurcation Structure

In the thermodynamic limit ($N \rightarrow \infty$), the system can be described by semiclassical equations for the field quadratures $x, p$ and collective spin components $\mathbf{j} = (j_x, j_y, j_z)$: $$\begin{aligned} \dot{x} &= p - \frac{\kappa}{2} x \ \dot{p} &= -\omega^2 x - \frac{\kappa}{2} p - 2\lambda(t) \sqrt{2\omega} j_x \ \frac{d\mathbf{j}}{dt} &= \big[ \omega_0 e_z + 2\lambda(t)\sqrt{2\omega}x e_x \big] \times \mathbf{j} \end{aligned}$$ As a function of detuning and imperfect parity operation, a rich dynamical phase diagram emerges:

• Stable period-doubled (DTC) orbits, with observables changing sign each period.
• Asymmetric period-doubling: two states not related by simple inversion symmetry.
• Period sextupling and higher-multiplet return orbits.
• Bifurcations, including pitchfork bifurcation marking symmetry-breaking onset.

This structure is confirmed both by direct time evolution and by mapping phase-space trajectories on the Bloch sphere and examining statistical measures such as synchronization probability distributions.

4. DTC Behavior in the Quantum Regime

For small $N$ (deep quantum regime, $N=2,3$), the system is not amenable to a semiclassical approximation. Exact diagonalization shows that, provided strong coupling and moderate dissipation, stroboscopic expectation values of odd-parity observables (e.g., $j_x$ or $x$) still display pronounced period-doubling. This DTC signal persists for durations greatly exceeding the bare dissipation time $\kappa^{-1}$ and is completely absent in the absence of dissipation (unitary evolution), where irregular, nonperiodic trajectories dominate. The dissipative channel thus acts constructively even in few-qubit systems, stabilizing transient DTC behavior unavailable in closed, isolated models.

5. Floquet–Lindblad–Landau Framework and Universal Lifetime

A phenomenological generalization of Landau theory to periodically driven open systems is constructed by adiabatic elimination of the atomic degrees of freedom, yielding an effective Floquet–Lindblad–Landau Hamiltonian for the photonic mode: $$H_L = \omega a^\dagger a - \frac{\Omega_2}{4}(a + a^\dagger)^2 + \frac{\Omega_4}{32N}(a + a^\dagger)^4$$ accompanied by photon dissipation. This effective field theory retains the parity symmetry and enables spectral analysis of the associated Floquet–Lindblad superoperator. The key universal feature is the presence of a mode with eigenvalue very close to $-1$, corresponding to the DTC order, whose correction vanishes exponentially with $N$ [i.e., $~\exp(-cN)$]. This leads to a DTC lifetime that is exponentially long in system size, establishing a robust non-equilibrium phase even in the presence of noise and drive imperfections.

6. Mathematical Structure and Central Equations

The theoretical apparatus for analyzing discrete time-crystal phases in this context is grounded in the following structures:

• Lindblad master equation with time-dependent coupling $H(\lambda)$,
• Stroboscopically modulated coupling protocol,
• Semiclassical evolution equations for quadratures and pseudospin,
• Effective Landau-type field theory with even quartic nonlinearity and parity symmetry,
• Floquet–Lindblad spectral analysis to identify signatures of DTC order and quantify the associated lifetime.

The general stroboscopic Floquet map combines Floquet theory for periodically driven systems with dissipative quantum dynamics, extending the equilibrium symmetry-breaking paradigm into open, time-dependent contexts.

7. Implications and Experimental Prospects

The driven-dissipative open Dicke model demonstrates the stabilization of DTC order both in the thermodynamic limit and in few-qubit systems through modulated atom–light coupling and engineered dissipation (Gong et al., 2017). The model exhibits a crossover from stable and diverse dynamical phases (including multiplet period oscillations and limit-cycle pairs) in large $N$ to sharp, long-lived transient subharmonic oscillations in small $N$. The effective Floquet–Lindblad–Landau theory provides a unifying description of universal scaling and DTC lifetimes across regimes.

State-of-the-art cavity and circuit QED platforms are positioned to realize and test these predictions, probing time-translation symmetry breaking via stroboscopic measurements of photonic quadratures or atomic pseudospins. The analysis generalizes to other driven open quantum systems exhibiting spontaneous temporal ordering and supplies a concrete mathematical and experimental roadmap for characterizing discrete time-crystal phases beyond one-dimensional and closed-system paradigms.

---

Summary Table: Key Theoretical Components in Discrete Time-Crystal Phases (Gong et al., 2017)

Aspect	Mathematical Object	Physical Role
Open system dynamics	$$d\rho/dt = -i[H(\lambda), \rho] + \kappa{\cal D}[a]\rho$$	Stabilization via dissipation
Modulated Dicke model	$$H(\lambda) = \omega a^\dagger a + \omega_0 J_z + \cdots$$	Many-body atom–light coupling
Drive protocol	$\lambda(t+T)$ piecewise constant	Implements parity flip
Semiclassics	System of ODEs for $(x, p, \mathbf{j})$	Dynamical phases and bifurcations
Effective field theory	$H_L$ (Floquet–Lindblad–Landau)	Universal DTC features
Lifetime analysis	Floquet spectrum with eigenvalue $\sim -1$	Exponentially long DTC time

This comprehensive framework offers a rigorous foundation for understanding, predicting, and experimentally realizing discrete time-crystalline order in open, periodically driven quantum systems.