Congruence Monoid Primes: Distribution & Factorization

• Congruence monoid primes are prime-like elements defined within multiplicative submonoids restricted by congruence conditions, central to analyzing factorization and distribution.
• They are characterized using specialized counting functions and invariants like omega primality, length density, and catenary degree, which quantify deviations from unique factorization.
• These primes extend classical notions into geometric, combinatorial, and noncommutative frameworks, enabling advanced research in algebraic geometry and analytic number theory.

A congruence monoid prime is a prime-like element within multiplicative submonoids of the integers or related algebraic structures, where membership is determined by congruence conditions. The prime notion inherits from both ring and monoid theory but interacts with arithmetic and combinatorial constraints unique to its setting. As investigated across several domains, congruence monoid primes enable refined understanding of factorization, distribution, and algebraic geometry over non-classical bases; their paper draws on analytic number theory, combinatorial algebra, and scheme-theoretic generalizations.

1. Definition and Foundational Properties

A congruence monoid $M$ is typically a subset of $\mathbb{N}$ closed under multiplication and defined by a congruence condition such as $M_{a,b} = \{ a, a+b, a+2b, \ldots \} \cup \{1\}$, where $a^2 \equiv a \pmod{b}$ (Chapman et al., 2022). More generally, monoids may be described as $A_d = \{ n \in \mathbb{N} : n \equiv 1 \pmod{d} \}$ (Cai et al., 17 Oct 2025). An element $p \in M$ (with $p \ne 1$) is a congruence monoid prime if, whenever $p = ab$ for $a, b \in M$, one has $a = 1$ or $b = 1$. This definition deliberately excludes non-monoid factorizations, often inflating the prime count compared to the classical setting.

In geometric contexts, the notion generalizes: the spectrum of a sesquiad—a monoid paired with a universal ring encoding partial addition—is denoted $\operatorname{spec}_c A$; its prime congruences are equivalence relations compatible with both monoid multiplication and ring-induced addition (Deitmar, 2011). These 'congruence monoid primes' behave analogously to prime ideals, governing localizations and residue sesquiads, and are central to the arithmetic information encoded by congruence schemes.

2. Distribution and Counting Functions

The distribution of congruence monoid primes in $A_d$ diverges from the classical prime number theorem for $\mathbb{N}$. The heuristic estimate for their count up to $x$ is

$T_{d}(x) \sim \frac{x}{d (\ln x)^{1/d}}$

where $T_{d}(x)$ is the number of monoid primes in $A_d$ less than $x$ (Cai et al., 17 Oct 2025). The normalized ratio

$R_{d}(x) = \frac{T_{d}(x)}{x/(d (\ln x)^{1/d})}$

remains near $1$ over a broad range of $x$, supporting the accuracy of this model, although corrections are necessary as $x$ increases. This reflects a delicate balance: $A_d$ is thinner than $\mathbb{N}$, but elements composite in $\mathbb{N}$ may be prime in $A_d$ by virtue of restricted factorization.

Empirical evidence (tables, ratios, plots) substantiates these predictions for diverse values of $d$, with mean absolute percentage errors between $2\%$ and $9\%$ (Cai et al., 17 Oct 2025). The methodology extends to the norm-based counting of Gaussian primes, yielding

$T_G(r) \sim \frac{1}{2}\frac{r^2}{\ln r},$

where $T_G(r)$ counts first-quadrant Gaussian primes of norm at most $r$.

3. Factorization Theory in Arithmetical Congruence Monoids

Congruence monoid primes are pivotal for understanding non-unique factorization phenomena. Quantitative invariants elucidate this structure:

• Omega Primality ($\omega$):

$$\omega(x) = \min\{ m \mid x \mid a_1a_2\cdots a_k,\, k > m \implies \exists S \subsetneq \{1,\dots,k\},\ x \mid \prod_{i \in S} a_i \}$$

$\omega(x)$ detects how far $x$ is from being prime; $\omega(x) = 1$ characterizes primes, with explicit formulas relating $\omega(x)$ to the parameters $a$, $b$ in $M_{a,b}$.

• Length Density: Measures the variability of factorization lengths:

$LD(x) = \frac{\max L(x) - \min L(x)}{|L(x)| - 1}$

Explicit calculations, e.g., $LD(M_{1,b}) = \varphi(b) - 2$ for regular ACMs with $\varphi$ the Euler totient.

• Catenary Degree ($c(x)$): Quantifies the minimal distance between factorizations; closed forms are derived for regular and singular ACMs (Chapman et al., 2022).

These invariants reflect how congruence monoid primes structure the arithmetic, with large omega values or catenary degrees indicating elements that deviate from unique factorization.

4. Congruence Schemes, Local Structure, and Zeta Functions

The sesquiad-based framework lifts the notion of congruence monoid primes into the setting of algebraic geometry over semirings and provides an enriched categorization. A prime congruence determines localizations and residue sesquiads with associated norms $N(x) = |K(x)|$ leading to Hasse–Weil type zeta functions

$$\zeta_X(s) = \prod_{x \in |X|_z} \frac{1}{1 - N(x)^{-s}}$$

where $|X|_z$ is the set of $Z$-closed points (Deitmar, 2011). These constructions generalize prime decomposition and factorization theory in ring spectra, encoding deeper number-theoretical structure than available in purely combinatorial monoid schemes.

5. Decomposition Theory and Mesoprimary Structure

Congruence monoid primes appear as central actors in the mesoprimary decomposition of congruences:

• A congruence $\sim$ on a monoid $Q$ can be decomposed as

$\sim = \bigcap_{w \in W} \sim_w^P$

where $\sim_w^P$ corresponds to a coprincipal mesoprimary component cogenerated by the witness $w$ for monoid prime $P$ (Kahle et al., 2011, O'Neill, 2017). The decomposition is canonical and irredundant relative to true witnesses.

• Associated prime objects encapsulate both the monoid prime and combinatorial (character) data, lifting to binomial mesoprimary decomposition (Kahle et al., 2011).
• Every finite poset can be realized as the poset of truly associated prime congruences, confirming the combinatorial richness and flexibility inherent in congruence monoid prime structures (O'Neill, 2017).

6. Extensions and the Role in Unusual Algebraic Domains

The notion of congruence monoid prime generalizes beyond the integers:

• In noncommutative ("natural") monoids, primes are defined via castling: a prime $p$ satisfies that for any factorization $uv$ in the monoid, either $p \mid u$ or $p$ is a castled divisor of $v$ over $u$ (Xue, 2019). Complexity measures such as $$\mathcal{C}(S) = \sup_{1 \neq u \in S} \tau_0(u)/\tau(u)$$ (with $\mathcal{C}(\mathbb{N}) = 1/2$, $\mathcal{C}(\mathbb{S}) = 1$) quantify the divisorial explosion under repeated castlings.
• In quadratic extensions or Gaussian integers, counting prime elements involves additional complications such as unit groups and non-unique factorization, necessitating geometric adaptations in prime-counting heuristics (Cai et al., 17 Oct 2025).

A plausible implication is that similar combinatorial and analytic methodologies may yield prime distribution theorems for other algebraic structures, including rings of integers in number fields, when one properly accounts for arithmetic and congruence constraints.

7. Analytical and Computational Methodologies

Recent computational approaches for analyzing congruence monoid primes include:

• Low-index congruence algorithms, utilizing word graphs and combinatorial pruning, to enumerate and classify congruence classes in semigroups and monoids (Anagnostopoulou-Merkouri et al., 2023).
• Principal congruence joins and meet decomposition leveraging relative Green’s relations and Schreier’s Lemma for monoids, allowing efficient calculation of the lattice of congruences and isolation of irreducible (prime) congruences.
• Empirical evaluation and refinement of heuristic models for the distribution of congruence monoid primes, guiding both conjecture formation and algorithmic development (Cai et al., 17 Oct 2025).

The intersection of theoretical analysis and computational implementation is instrumental in advancing both experimental and rigorous results in the paper of congruence monoid primes.

---

In summary, congruence monoid primes generalize classical primeness via arithmetic and combinatorial constraints imposed by congruence monoids and their associated algebraic or geometric structures. Their paper spans counting functions and distribution in non-classical domains, combinatorial and arithmetic factorization theory, geometric and scheme-theoretic localizations, and algorithmic computation of congruence lattices, each elucidating different facets of primeness outside the traditional setting of commutative rings.