Small graphs without power-of-two cycles: a lower bound of 24, a correction to a construction of Exoo, and explicit bounds for f(k)

Abstract: The Erdos-Gyarfas conjecture states that every graph with minimum degree at least 3 contains a cycle whose length is a power of two. We prove by a SAT-based exhaustive search, certified by DRAT proofs, that every graph with minimum degree at least 3 on at most 23 vertices contains a cycle of length 4 or a cycle of length 8; consequently any counterexample has at least 24 vertices, improving the previously published bound of 16, and the smallest graph of minimum degree 3 with no 4-cycle and no 8-cycle has exactly 24 vertices. We show that the lemma underlying Exoo's 450-vertex construction for the bound f(5) at most 450 is false: the Tutte-Coxeter graph contains 8-cycles alternating between outer and chord edges, and the graph as specified contains 32-cycles. We repair the construction and verify the corrected graph, so the bound stands. We also give an exact window calculus for vertex-replacement constructions, prove that f(k) is at most 15 times the order of the smallest known cubic graph of girth 2 to the power (k-2) plus 1 for all k at least 4 (in particular f(6) is at most 32640, the first bound for f(6)), and show that Exoo's 78-vertex witness for f(4) at most 78 is optimal among gadget designs on bases with at most 12 vertices. All graphs, scripts and certificates are archived at doi:10.5281/zenodo.22180583.