Extremal Asymmetric Depth of Planar Graphs and Hidden Near-Mirror Symmetries of IPR Fullerenes

Abstract: Although almost all graphs are asymmetric -- having no nontrivial global automorphisms -- they may still possess local symmetries in the form of isomorphisms between induced subgraphs, i.e., partial automorphisms. We study such local symmetries via asymmetric depth, defined in terms of the maximum rank of a nontrivial partial automorphism. We prove a tight upper bound on asymmetric depth in the class of planar graphs and identify the extremal graphs: duals of IPR fullerenes attain the maximum already on $47$ vertices. Our main structural result concerns the IPR fullerenes that are neither maximally asymmetric nor symmetric. In such a cage no purely local action realises a low asymmetric depth, and we show that the map which does realise it cannot be confined to a small part of the cage either: neither to a single face, nor behind an interface of at most $5-k$ edges, $k \le 3$ being the deficiency. A cage of asymmetric depth $2$ or $3$ is therefore not asymmetric in one place; it carries a broken symmetry invisible to its automorphism group. Such cages are rare -- under $2\%$ of the asymmetric IPR fullerenes at $n = 118$. In all $727$ of them the largest partial automorphism is a near-mirror reflection, which we state as an explicit conjecture. We also extend the asymmetric depth bound to graphs of higher genus.