Critical collapse of vacuum spacetimes: Nakamura wave initial data

Abstract: We report on numerical simulations of critical phenomena in the collapse of axisymmetric vacuum gravitational waves, adopting families of initial data that, to the best of our knowledge, have not been used in this context before. Like Teukolsky waves, the data are based on linear wave solutions to the Einstein equations. We follow Nakamura's construction and encode the wave content in the extrinsic curvature rather than the spatial curvature, which leads to several simplifications when the data are "dressed up" so that they satisfy the nonlinear constraint equations. We are able to fine-tune these data to the onset of black hole formation slightly better than in our previous simulations, allowing us to observe and examine one more echo in the approximately self-similar threshold solution. Our findings are consistent with earlier studies: while we find threshold solutions that are approximately discretely self-similar, the self-similarity is not exact, and we find no evidence for a unique critical solution. We discuss common features between the different threshold solutions, including the appearance of alternating maxima in the direction of the poles and the equator.