Techno-economic Analysis of Light Isotope-enriched Elements for Lightweighting Applications

Abstract: Lightweighting is critical to mass-sensitive applications such as aircraft and space transportation. Conventional lightweight strategies often rely on new designs of materials and structures. An alternative approach is to enrich the lightest stable isotopes in an element to reduce the elements atomic mass while having little effect on structural and chemical properties. However, the economic feasibility of this concept remains unclear. Here we present a techno-economic analysis of light isotope-enriched elements for lightweighting applications by estimating isotope enrichment cost and the economic gain from mass reduction. The enrichment cost is scaled from established large-scale processes. Twelve common aerospace-relevant elements are considered, including Li, B, C, Mg, Cl, Ti, Ni, Fe, Cu, Zn, Mo, and Sn. We find that nine elements, especially Li, B, Zn, Ni, Mo, and Sn, show potentially attractive economic benefit at moderate enrichment levels, whereas C, Mg, and Fe provide little or no benefit. With the optimized enrichment levels, an Airbus A380 is expected to save approximately USD 700 K over a 30-year operational lifetime, a SpaceX Falcon 9 could save USD 516 K, and a SpaceX Starship is expected to save USD 2.37 million over its whole lifetime. While the exact enrichment cost needs to be further investigated, these results provide an initial screening of promising candidate elements and highlight isotopic mass reduction as a potential drop-in lightweighting strategy.