AI-Specific Code Smells: From Specification to Detection

Abstract: The rise of AI is reshaping how software systems are developed and maintained. However, AI-based systems give rise to new software issues that existing detection tools often miss. Among these, we focus on AI-specific code smells, recurring patterns in the code that may indicate deeper problems such as unreproducibility, silent failures, or poor model generalization. We introduce SpecDetect4AI, a tool-based approach for the specification and detection of these code smells at scale. This approach combines a high-level declarative Domain-Specific Language (DSL) for rule specification with an extensible static analysis tool that interprets and detects these rules for AI-based systems. We specified 22 AI-specific code smells and evaluated SpecDetect4AI on 826 AI-based systems (20M lines of code), achieving a precision of 88.66% and a recall of 88.89%, outperforming other existing detection tools. Our results show that SpecDetect4AI supports the specification and detection of AI-specific code smells through dedicated rules and can effectively analyze large AI-based systems, demonstrating both efficiency and extensibility (SUS 81.7/100).