Asymmetric graph alignment and the phase transition for asymmetric tree correlation testing

Abstract: Graph alignment - identifying node correspondences between two graphs - is a fundamental problem with applications in network analysis, biology, and privacy research. While substantial progress has been made in aligning correlated Erd\H{o}s-R\'enyi graphs under symmetric settings, real-world networks often exhibit asymmetry in both node numbers and edge densities. In this work, we introduce a novel framework for asymmetric correlated Erd\H{o}s-R\'enyi graphs, generalizing existing models to account for these asymmetries. We conduct a rigorous theoretical analysis of graph alignment in the sparse regime, where local neighborhoods exhibit tree-like structures. Our approach leverages tree correlation testing as the central tool in our polynomial-time algorithm, MPAlign, which achieves one-sided partial alignment under certain conditions. A key contribution of our work is characterizing these conditions under which asymmetric tree correlation testing is feasible: If two correlated graphs $G$ and $G'$ have average degrees $\lambda s$ and $\lambda s'$ respectively, where $\lambda$ is their common density and $s,s'$ are marginal correlation parameters, their tree neighborhoods can be aligned if $ss' > \alpha$, where $\alpha$ denotes Otter's constant and $\lambda$ is supposed large enough. The feasibility of this tree comparison problem undergoes a sharp phase transition since $ss' \leq \alpha$ implies its impossibility. These new results on tree correlation testing allow us to solve a class of random subgraph isomorphism problems, resolving an open problem in the field.