Fundamental elements in the development of effective crowd control strategies

Abstract: In this work, we present typical challenges encountered when developing methods for controlling crowds of people (or animal swarms). We discuss which elements shall be considered and the role they play to achieve a robust control in a variety of conditions. In particular, four different studies are reviewed, each of them investigating in detail important elements encountered in crowd steering and control. More specifically synchronization, compliance, crowd (or swarm) density and human perception are studied showing the role they play in combination. Ultimately, the success of a control strategy is determined by carefully considering the effect each element has on individuals, but also on the interactions between them, leading to the creation of a collective behavior. We will also highlight the importance of psychological and cognitive factors when dealing with human crowds, hinting at the fact that automatic control systems may achieve optimal performance, but may be not necessarily well perceived by people in terms of comfort. The discussion aims at showing recent trends and potentialities of crowd control systems, but should also warn on the risk in choosing a solution prioritizing optimization toward people's safety or comfort.