Causal features in turbulent channel flow

Abstract: The causal relevance of local flow conditions in wall-bounded turbulence is analysed using ensembles of interventional experiments in which the effect of perturbing the flow within a small cell is monitored at some future time. When this is done using the relative amplification of the perturbation energy, causality depends on the flow conditions within the cell before it is perturbed, and can be used as a probe of the flow dynamics. The key scaling parameter is the ambient shear, which is also the dominant diagnostic variable for wall-attached perturbations. Away from the wall, the relevant variables are the streamwise and wall-normal velocities. Causally significant cells are associated with sweeps that carry the perturbation towards the stronger shear near the wall, whereas irrelevant ones are associated with ejections that carry it towards the weaker shear in the outer layers. Causally significant and irrelevant cells are themselves organised into structures that share many characteristics with classical sweeps and ejections, such as forming spanwise pairs whose dimensions and geometry are similar to those of classical quadrants. At the wall, this is consistent with causally significant configurations in which a high-speed streak overtakes a low-speed one, and causally irrelevant ones in which the two streaks pull apart from each other. It is argued that this is probably associated with streak meandering.