Testing analytical methods to derive the cosmic-ray ionisation rate in cold regions via synthetic observations

Abstract: Cosmic rays (CRs) heavily impact the chemistry and physics of cold and dense star-forming regions. However, characterising their ionisation rate is still challenging from an observational point of view. In the past, a few analytical formulas have been proposed to infer the cosmic-ray ionization rate $\zeta_2$ from molecular line observations. These have been derived from the chemical kinetics of the involved species, but they have not been validated using synthetic data processed with a standard observative pipeline. We aim to bridge this gap. We perform the radiative transfer on a set of three-dimensional magneto-hydrodynamical simulations of prestellar cores, exploring different initial $\zeta_2$, evolutionary stages, types of radiative transfer (e.g. assuming local-thermodynamic-equilibrium conditions), and telescope responses. We then compute the column densities of the involved tracers to determine $\zeta_2$, using, in particular, the equation proposed by Bovino et. al (2020) and by Caselli et al. (1998) both used nowadays. Our results confirm that the method of Bovino et al. (2020) accurately retrieves the actual $\zeta_2$ within a factor of $2-3$, in the physical conditions explored in our tests. Since we also explore a non-local thermodynamic equilibrium radiative transfer, this work indirectly offers insights into the excitation temperatures of common transitions at moderate volume densities ($n\approx 10^5 \, \rm cm^{-3}$). We have also performed a few tests using the formula proposed by Caselli et al. (1998), which overestimates the actual $\zeta_2$ by at least two orders of magnitudes. We also consider a new derivation of this method, which, however, still leads to large overestimates.