Theoretical comparison of real-time feedback-driven single-particle tracking techniques

Abstract: Real-time feedback-driven single-particle tracking is a technique that uses feedback control to enable single-molecule spectroscopy of freely diffusing particles in native or near-native environments. A number of different RT-FD-SPT approaches exist, and comparisons between methods based on experimental results are of limited use due to differences in samples and setups. In this study, we used statistical calculations and dynamical simulations to directly compare the performance of different methods. The methods considered were the orbital method, the Knights Tour (grid scan) method and MINFLUX, and we considered both fluorescence-based and interferometric scattering (iSCAT) approaches. There is a fundamental trade-off between precision and speed, with the Knights Tour method being able to track the fastest diffusion but with low precision, and MINFLUX being the most precise but only tracking slow diffusion. To compare iSCAT and fluorescence, different biological samples were considered, including labeled and intrinsically fluorescent samples. The success of iSCAT as compared to fluorescence is strongly dependent on the particle size and the density and photophysical properties of the fluorescent particles. Using a wavelength for iSCAT that is negligibly absorbed by the tracked particle allows an increased illumination intensity, which results in iSCAT providing better tracking for most samples. This work highlights the fundamental aspects of performance in RT-FD-SPT and should assist with the selection of an appropriate method for a particular application. The approach used can easily be extended to other RT-FD-SPT methods.