Strong Conformity and Assembly Bias: Towards a Physical Understanding of the Galaxy-Halo Connection in SDSS Clusters

Abstract: Understanding the physical connection between cluster galaxies and massive haloes is key to mitigating systematic uncertainties in next-generation cluster cosmology. We develop a novel method to infer the level of conformity between the stellar mass of the brightest central galaxies~(BCGs) $M_^{BCG}$ and the satellite richness $\lambda$, defined as their correlation coefficient $\rho_{cc}$ at fixed halo mass, using the abundance and weak lensing of SDSS clusters as functions of $M_^{BCG}$ and $\lambda$. We detect a halo mass-dependent conformity as $\rho_{cc}{=}0.60{+}0.08\ln(M_h/3{\times}10^{14}M_{\odot}/h)$. The strong conformity successfully resolves the "halo mass equality" conundrum discovered in Zu et al. 2021 -- when split by $M_^{BCG}$ at fixed $\lambda$, the low and high-$M_^{BCG}$ clusters have the same average halo mass despite having a $0.34$ dex discrepancy in average $M_^{BCG}$. On top of the best-fitting conformity model, we develop a cluster assembly bias~(AB) prescription calibrated against the CosmicGrowth simulation, and build a conformity+AB model for the cluster weak lensing measurements. Our model predicts that with a ${\sim}20\%$ lower halo concentration $c$, the low-$M_^{BCG}$ clusters are ${\sim}10\%$ more biased than the high-$M_^{BCG}$ systems, in excellent agreement with the observations. We also show that the observed conformity and assembly bias are unlikely due to projection effects. Finally, we build a toy model to argue that while the early-time BCG-halo co-evolution drives the $M_^{BCG}$-$c$ correlation, the late-time dry merger-induced BCG growth naturally produces the $M_*^{BCG}$-$\lambda$ conformity despite the well-known anti-correlation between $\lambda$ and $c$. Our method paves the path towards simultaneously constraining cosmology and cluster formation with future cluster surveys.