Search for $μ^- \rightarrow e^+$ conversion: what can be learned from the SINDRUM-II positron data on a gold target

Abstract: In their 2006 paper setting the current limit on \mumemconv\ conversion search on a gold target \cite{sindrum_ii:Bertl2006}, the SINDRUM-II collaboration published, along with the electron momentum distribution, the momentum distribution of reconstructed positrons. Near the positron spectrum endpoint, there is a statistically significant excess of observed events over the expected background. We estimate that in the region 88 MeV/c < p < 95 MeV/c there are 13 events with an expected background of about 1-1.5 event, which has not been discussed by the authors. Those 13 events form a bump with a width consistent with the experimental resolution, making one think of a $\mu^- \rightarrow e^+$ conversion signal. However, the reconstructed position of the bump is about 1 MeV/c, or $\sim\ 4\sigma_p$, lower than the expected $\mu^- Au \rightarrow e^+ Ir $ signal, which strongly discourages the exotic interpretation. The excess, however, could be due to an exclusive dipole radiative muon capture (RMC) transition $^{197}Au(GS) ~\rightarrow~ ^{197}Pt(GS)$ with the branching fraction of about $2\cdot 10^{-4}$. Such a transition would not be resolved by the existing RMC measurements. We conclude that the exclusive RMC transitions could significantly modify the positron spectrum near the kinematic endpoint, to fully exploit the physics potential of the upcoming experiments such as Mu2e and COMET, a better theoretical understanding of the RMC spectrum on nuclei is needed. A high-resolution measurement of the RMC photon spectra has to be carried out. Without that, the sensitivity of the searches for $\mu^- \rightarrow e^+$ and $\mu^- \rightarrow e^-$ might be severely limited by unknown probabilities of RMC transitions to the exclusive low-lying states of the daughter nuclei.