Efficient Estimation of Pathwise Differentiable Target Parameters with the Undersmoothed Highly Adaptive Lasso

Abstract: We consider estimation of a functional parameter of a realistically modeled data distribution based on observing independent and identically distributed observations. We define an $m$-th order Spline Highly Adaptive Lasso Minimum Loss Estimator (Spline HAL-MLE) of a functional parameter that is defined by minimizing the empirical risk function over an $m$-th order smoothness class of functions. We show that this $m$-th order smoothness class consists of all functions that can be represented as an infinitesimal linear combination of tensor products of $\leq m$-th order spline-basis functions, and involves assuming $m$-derivatives in each coordinate. By selecting $m$ with cross-validation we obtain a Spline-HAL-MLE that is able to adapt to the underlying unknown smoothness of the true function, while guaranteeing a rate of convergence faster than $n^{-1/4}$, as long as the true function is cadlag (right-continuous with left-hand limits) and has finite sectional variation norm. The $m=0$-smoothness class consists of all cadlag functions with finite sectional variation norm and corresponds with the original HAL-MLE defined in van der Laan (2015). In this article we establish that this Spline-HAL-MLE yields an asymptotically efficient estimator of any smooth feature of the functional parameter under an easily verifiable global undersmoothing condition. A sufficient condition for the latter condition is that the minimum of the empirical mean of the selected basis functions is smaller than a constant times $n^{-1/2}$, which is not parameter specific and enforces the selection of the $L_1$-norm in the lasso to be large enough to include sparsely supported basis. We demonstrate our general result for the $m=0$-HAL-MLE of the average treatment effect and of the integral of the square of the data density. We also present simulations for these two examples confirming the theory.