Zigzag transitions and nonequilibrium pattern formation in colloidal chains

Abstract: Paramagnetic colloidal particles that are optically trapped in a linear array can form a zigzag pattern when an external magnetic field induces repulsive interparticle interactions. When the traps are abruptly turned off, the particles form a nonequilibrium expanding pattern with a zigzag symmetry, even when the strength of the magnetic interaction is weaker than that required to break the linear symmetry of the equilibrium state. We show that the transition to the equilibrium zigzag state is always potentially possible for purely harmonic traps. For anharmonic traps that have a finite height, the equilibrium zigzag state becomes unstable above a critical anharmonicity. A normal mode analysis of the equilibrium line configuration demonstrates that increasing the magnetic field leads to a hardening and softening of the spring constants in the longitudinal and transverse directions, respectively. The mode that first becomes unstable is the mode with the zigzag symmetry, which explains the symmetry of nonequilibrium patterns. Our analytically tractable models help to give further insight into the way that the interplay of such factors as the length of the chain, hydrodynamic interactions, thermal fluctuations affect the formation and evolution of the experimentally observed nonequilibrium patterns.