General Truthfulness Characterizations Via Convex Analysis

Abstract: We present a model of truthful elicitation which generalizes and extends mechanisms, scoring rules, and a number of related settings that do not qualify as one or the other. Our main result is a characterization theorem, yielding characterizations for all of these settings, including a new characterization of scoring rules for non-convex sets of distributions. We generalize this model to eliciting some property of the agent's private information, and provide the first general characterization for this setting. We combine this characterization with duality to give a simple construction to convert between scoring rules and randomized mechanisms. We also show how this characterization gives a new proof of a mechanism design result due to Saks and Yu.