Totally balanced curves and complex multiplication

Determine whether, for a fixed prime \(\ell\) and a Galois extension \(K/\mathbb{Q}\) of odd degree, every elliptic curve over \(K\) that is totally balanced at \(\ell\) has complex multiplication.

Background

The paper shows that totally balanced elliptic curves over Galois extensions of Q\mathbb{Q} of odd degree have trace behavior closely analogous to that of CM elliptic curves: their trace modulo ℓ\ell lies in a proper subset of Fℓ\mathbb{F}_\ell. It remains unresolved whether this similarity reflects an actual structural characterization, namely whether total balancedness forces complex multiplication.

The question is specifically posed for a fixed prime ℓ\ell and a Galois number field of odd degree, and the paper emphasizes that this issue differs from the quadratic case because balancedness need not determine a unique representation type in higher degree.

References

It remains an open question whether for a fixed prime $\ell$ and $K$ a Galois extension of $Q$ of odd degree, if all elliptic curves $E/K$ which are totally balanced at $\ell$ must also have complex multiplication.

— Heavenly Elliptic Curves over Cubic Number Fields  (2609.35642 - O'Hara, 28 Sep 2026) in Section 1, final paragraph before Acknowledgments