Dice Question Streamline Icon: https://streamlinehq.com

Existence of semantically justified set axioms beyond ZF

Ascertain whether there exist set-theoretic axioms beyond the Zermelo–Fraenkel axioms that admit semantic justification grounded in an objective conception of the set-theoretic universe, and identify such axioms if they exist.

Information Square Streamline Icon: https://streamlinehq.com

Background

The authors distinguish semantic and syntactic justifications of axioms, noting Gödel’s preference for semantic grounding via intuition of the set-theoretic universe. While ZF axioms have semantic justification in this framework, the paper explicitly states uncertainty about whether any additional set-theoretic axioms enjoy such semantic justification.

Resolving this question is central to the pursuit of a more complete, objectively grounded axiomatization of set theory, particularly regarding large cardinal axioms and consequences for undecidable statements.

References

It is not clear whether, besides the ZF axioms, there are other set-theoretic axioms with semantic justification (see [1]).

Kurt Gödel and the Logic of Concepts (2406.05442 - Kostić et al., 8 Jun 2024) in Section 3.2.1