Dice Question Streamline Icon: https://streamlinehq.com

Repairing the linear-regression approximation for non-monotonic output series

Develop a linear-regression-based approximation for estimating the parameters β and λ in the Jones law of motion dA/A = θ A^{−β} I^{λ} that remains valid when the output series A(t) is non-monotonic or locally flat, thereby avoiding the current requirement that A(t2) > A(t1) over each sampling window and resolving the conflict between choosing large windows to enforce monotonicity and small windows to control input variance.

Information Square Streamline Icon: https://streamlinehq.com

Background

In the linear-regression approach derived from the integral form of the Jones law of motion, the left-hand side involves log log(A(t2)/A(t1)). This forces A(t) to be strictly increasing over each sampling window; otherwise the expression becomes undefined or diverges to negative infinity.

The authors note that many empirical output series (e.g., TFP) exhibit flat or decreasing periods, making the strict monotonicity requirement unrealistic. While selecting larger sampling windows can enforce A(t2) > A(t1), this clashes with the need for short windows to keep the variance of inputs I(t) low, producing a methodological impasse.

A principled repair of the linear-regression approximation that works when A(t) is not strictly increasing would enable broader applicability of regression-based estimation without resorting to ad hoc window selection.

References

Unfortunately, it is not clear how to repair the method so it generalizes to this case. Picking t1, t2 such that t2 - t1 is always big enough for A(t2) > A(t1) is sometimes good enough to get some results out of the method, but it is rather unprincipled and in tension with the need to make t2 - t1 small to ensure var_{t \sim (t1, t2)}(I) \ll \mathbb E_{t \sim (t1, t2)}[I]2.

Estimating Idea Production: A Methodological Survey (2405.10494 - Erdil et al., 17 May 2024) in Section 5.7, The output series must be strictly increasing