Intermediate fragment between CM and CM + GWO with weaker strength but comparable utility
Identify a theory fragment extending CM and strictly weaker in proof‑theoretic strength than CM + GWO that nonetheless proves the principal mathematical results obtained via the global well‑ordering axioms, such as Zorn‑type maximality arguments and basis existence in vector spaces.
References
Moving away from Weaver's original proposal, it still remains open though whether one can find any interesting theory fragment lying between CM and CM + GWO that both
- has significantly weaker proof-theoretic strength than full CM + GWO; and
- can still prove most of the mathematical results we looked at in \autoref{sec:axiom-gwo}.
                — An ordinal analysis of CM and its extensions
                
                (2501.12631 - Wang, 22 Jan 2025) in Section 6 (A concluding remark on impredicativity)