The Hyperfinite-over-Hyperfinite Problem: Are hyperfinite-over-hyperfinite Borel equivalence relations hyperfinite?

Determine whether every hyperfinite-over-hyperfinite Borel equivalence relation—i.e., a Borel equivalence relation that admits a Borel assignment of linear orders on each class of type embeddable into the lexicographic order on Z×Z—is hyperfinite.

Background

Hyperfinite-over-hyperfinite equivalence relations are defined via the existence of a Borel Z2-ordering (lexicographic order on Z×Z) on each class. This generalizes the classical characterization of hyperfiniteness via class-wise Z-orderings.

The paper proves that a sufficient condition—self-compatibility of such a Z2-ordering—implies hyperfiniteness. However, in general it remains unknown whether every hyperfinite-over-hyperfinite relation must be hyperfinite.

References

As we stated in the introduction, the following problems are open. Problem 2.13 (The Hyperfinite-over-Hyperfinite Problem). Is every hyperfinite-over-hyperfinite equivalence relation hyperfinite?

— An order analysis of hyperfinite Borel equivalence relations  (2404.17516 - Gao et al., 2024) in Problem 2.13, Section 2

If $E$ is hf/hf, is it hyperfinite?

— Open Problems in Mathematical Logic  (2608.26628 - Barmpalias et al., 27 Aug 2026) in 2025 Section 12, subsection Some hyperfiniteness problems