Create and explore imaginative 3D worlds with our new product Dreamfield (opens in a new tab)

Higher-dimensional line-projection exceptional-set bound

Determine whether the inequality \(\dim_{\mathrm{?}} \mathcal E_1(F)\le d-2\) holds for every nonempty set \(F\subset\mathbb{R}^d\) when \(d\ge 3\), where \(\mathcal E_1(F)=\{V\in Gr(1,d):\dim_A(P_VF)<\min\{1,\dim_A F\}\}\).

Background

Fraser’s Question 17.8.1 proposes the general bound dim⁡Ek(F)≤k(d−1−k)\dim \mathcal E_k(F)\le k(d-1-k) for exceptional orthogonal projections. The paper disproves this bound for every 2≤k<d2\le k<d using compact cubes contained in kk-dimensional subspaces. It also explains that the planar case k=1,d=2k=1,d=2 is answered affirmatively by Wu’s countability theorem. The unresolved case identified here is the higher-dimensional line-projection situation, namely k=1k=1 in dimensions d≥3d\ge3.

The paper does not settle whether the proposed bound remains valid for arbitrary sources in this higher-dimensional line-projection case; its positive result applies only to certain sets contained in a two-dimensional subspace.

References

The higher-dimensional line-projection case of eq:question, and an optimal replacement for general k, are not resolved here.

eq:question:

Ek(F)≤k(d−1−k)(1≤k<d)\mathcal E_k(F)\le k(d-1-k)\qquad(1\le k<d)

— Orthogonal Projections and Assouad Dimension: Resolving Fraser's Questions  (2610.23295 - Selmi, 16 Oct 2026) in Section 1, Introduction

The higher-dimensional line-projection case of eq:question, and an optimal replacement for general k, are not resolved here.

eq:question:

Ek(F)≤k(d−1−k)(1≤k<d)\mathcal E_k(F)\le k(d-1-k)\qquad(1\le k<d)

— Orthogonal Projections and Assouad Dimension: Resolving Fraser's Questions  (2610.23295 - Selmi, 16 Oct 2026) in Section 1, Introduction